Sebastian man says two women he met at bar stole his firearms

Jenna Sims
Jenna Sims

SEBASTIAN – A man called police after the two women he met at a bar stole his firearms, according to the report.

The Sebastian man called 911 Wednesday at 1:26 a.m. to report a theft of two firearms that just occurred at his home, located at the 300 block of Helicon Terrace.

Officers observed two women near the homeowner’s location that matched the description. They were identified as Jenna Sims and Bethany O’Donnell, both from Tennessee.

Sims was carrying a firearm, a Heritage .22 caliber, that belonged to the victim. It was on the kitchen counter at the home.

The homeowner had a receipt that showed the serial number. However, the second handgun was not recovered. The victim said it was a Smith & Wesson 9mm semi-automatic handgun that he kept on his bed.

The victim told Sebastian police that he met the two at Earl’s Hideaway and invited them to his home after the bar closed.

Article continues below ...

Once at his home, Sims and O’Donnell “left the residence abruptly and Jenna appeared to have concealed items on her person prior to exiting the residence,” the officer said.

A few minutes later, the homeowner realized the two firearms were missing and called the police.

A criminal history check yielded in Jenna Sims being convicted of a felony in Indiana as of 11/25/2009.

Sims was arrested and charged with Grand Theft, Possession of a Firearm by a Convicted Felon, and Felony Carry Concealed Firearm.

Bond was set at $15,000. Sims has a court date on Wednesday, May 9, 2018.

Note: Make sure you signup for the Sebastian Daily Newsletter to stay informed with everything going on in Sebastian, Florida.
About Jennifer Balakrishnan 166 Articles
Jennifer Balakrishnan lives in Vero Beach, Florida. She moved to Indian River County when she was 6-years-old. Jennifer earned a bachelor’s degree at Florida State University. She writes our crime stories and is one of our food/restaurant critics.